“Dog-whistle” politics is deplorable in any country. But in India violence
between Hindus and Muslims is never far from the surface. At partition, when British India fractured, about 12m people were uprooted
and hundreds of thousands perished. Since 2002 communal violence has died down,
but there are hundreds of incidents and scores of deaths each year. Sometimes,
as in Uttar Pradesh, the violence is on an alarming scale. The spark could also
come from outside. In Mumbai in 2008 India suffered horrific attacks by
terrorists from Muslim Pakistan—a nagging, nuclear-armed presence next door.
By refusing to put Muslim fears to rest, Mr Modi feeds them. By clinging to the
anti-Muslim vote, he nurtures it. India at its finest is a joyous
cacophony of peoples and faiths, of holy men and rebels. The best of them, such
as the late columnist Khushwant Singh are painfully aware of the damage caused
by communal hatred. Mr Modi might start well in Delhi but sooner or later he
will have to cope with a sectarian slaughter or a crisis with Pakistan—and
nobody, least of all the modernisers praising him now, knows what he will do
nor how Muslims, in turn, will react to such a divisive man.
If Mr Modi were to explain his role in the violence and show genuine remorse,
we would consider backing him, but he never has; it would be wrong for a man
who has thrived on division to become prime minister of a country as fissile as
India. We do not find the prospect of a government led by Congress under Mr
Gandhi an inspiring one. But we have to recommend it to Indians as the less
disturbing option.
If Congress wins, which is unlikely, it must strive to renew itself and to
reform India.
Mr Gandhi should make a virtue of his diffidence by stepping back from politics
and promoting modernisers to the fore. There are plenty of them and modernity
is what Indian voters increasingly demand. If, more probably, victory goes to
the BJP, its coalition partners should hold out for a prime minister other than
Mr Modi.
And if they still choose Mr Modi? We would wish him well, and we would be
delighted for him to prove us wrong by governing India in a modern, honest and fair
way. But for now he should be judged on his record—which is that of a man who
is still associated with sectarian hatred. There is nothing modern, honest or
fair about that. India
deserves better.
[ Courtesy- an article- 'The Economist Agrees that Modi
is Disgusting & Evil' - on April 5th]